{
  "spec": {
    "id": "ema-confirmation-v1",
    "source": "https://data.binance.vision/data/spot/monthly/klines/BTCUSDT/1m/",
    "market": "Binance Spot BTCUSDT",
    "research_start": "2024-04-01",
    "holdout_start": "2024-07-01",
    "end_exclusive": "2024-10-01",
    "warmup_minutes": 180,
    "fast": 10,
    "slow": 20,
    "confirmations": [
      1,
      2
    ],
    "initial_usdt": "10000",
    "quantity_btc": "0.001",
    "fee": "0.001",
    "slippage_bps": "0",
    "fill": "next minute open after a confirmed close",
    "holdout_position": "Flat for each strategy at each evaluation start; indicators warm on preceding bars",
    "end_valuation": "Mark open positions at last close without forced liquidation",
    "decision": "Reject if holdout net PnL improvement <= 0; otherwise evidence insufficient until risk threshold and nonzero slippage robustness are assessed"
  },
  "spec_sha256": "20d8694ad4622f52acdfb69d9b63714fe683a071b17a9273cb80f117a7dbe060",
  "sources": [
    {
      "url": "https://data.binance.vision/data/spot/monthly/klines/BTCUSDT/1m/BTCUSDT-1m-2024-03.zip",
      "sha256": "a9af86295eae839f1d072643c67eed7fcc47bb1d82c12ef312d041eec9511e7b"
    },
    {
      "url": "https://data.binance.vision/data/spot/monthly/klines/BTCUSDT/1m/BTCUSDT-1m-2024-04.zip",
      "sha256": "753040cbfaa72bf9b1fdc6253a3b521a9a174a664dfd0929a556be327b016bc6"
    },
    {
      "url": "https://data.binance.vision/data/spot/monthly/klines/BTCUSDT/1m/BTCUSDT-1m-2024-05.zip",
      "sha256": "0f709143f66a09acc430d24a5f27f9accd52689c23ce10f2c0b6ea26997bfa8a"
    },
    {
      "url": "https://data.binance.vision/data/spot/monthly/klines/BTCUSDT/1m/BTCUSDT-1m-2024-06.zip",
      "sha256": "90f4fc3f55918787848c71f4cd0f2f1a5851bbffaf6392e76e9ab555b7479d2b"
    },
    {
      "url": "https://data.binance.vision/data/spot/monthly/klines/BTCUSDT/1m/BTCUSDT-1m-2024-07.zip",
      "sha256": "9cfd749fd2027a0c6f261bed607b49dd1256369fb41b784934544a3676f8162e"
    },
    {
      "url": "https://data.binance.vision/data/spot/monthly/klines/BTCUSDT/1m/BTCUSDT-1m-2024-08.zip",
      "sha256": "6a1cac2a5482132dc5a030534aa028e2becc560877f2b93b7add90194f576c42"
    },
    {
      "url": "https://data.binance.vision/data/spot/monthly/klines/BTCUSDT/1m/BTCUSDT-1m-2024-09.zip",
      "sha256": "1e30f6091b05eeb7b0449735d749354b81ab429ab1449bae82a21e316db8eac3"
    }
  ],
  "decision": "证据不足",
  "research": {
    "minutes": 131040,
    "baseline": {
      "net_usdt": "-392.58588064000000",
      "gross_usdt": "-0.20200000000000",
      "fee_usdt": "392.38388064000000",
      "end_usdt": "9607.41411936000000",
      "end_btc": "0",
      "fills": 5972,
      "drawdown_pct": "3.932643531198719064190254305",
      "mean_closed_minutes": "21.95311453449430676490288011",
      "daily_net_usdt": {
        "2024-04-01": "-4.24948309000000",
        "2024-04-02": "-9.18910524000000",
        "2024-04-03": "-12.47850336000000",
        "2024-04-04": "-14.95347298000000",
        "2024-04-05": "-19.65572837000000",
        "2024-04-06": "-24.08461643000000",
        "2024-04-07": "-28.42565418000000",
        "2024-04-08": "-29.86707715000000",
        "2024-04-09": "-37.37905297000000",
        "2024-04-10": "-40.52970120000000",
        "2024-04-11": "-47.53610514000000",
        "2024-04-12": "-54.76667808000000",
        "2024-04-13": "-57.88657953000000",
        "2024-04-14": "-58.71749464000000",
        "2024-04-15": "-64.26081937000000",
        "2024-04-16": "-68.04692249000000",
        "2024-04-17": "-72.86153385000000",
        "2024-04-18": "-76.21228258000000",
        "2024-04-19": "-78.54002678000000",
        "2024-04-20": "-85.42035578000000",
        "2024-04-21": "-89.61657949000000",
        "2024-04-22": "-91.79600471000000",
        "2024-04-23": "-96.39095048000000",
        "2024-04-24": "-100.59099679000000",
        "2024-04-25": "-104.12038421000000",
        "2024-04-26": "-110.47853647000000",
        "2024-04-27": "-114.54969891000000",
        "2024-04-28": "-119.54321128000000",
        "2024-04-29": "-122.30630711000000",
        "2024-04-30": "-128.77205948000000",
        "2024-05-01": "-130.03433033000000",
        "2024-05-02": "-134.48339977000000",
        "2024-05-03": "-134.56790600000000",
        "2024-05-04": "-139.45875334000000",
        "2024-05-05": "-143.06887755000000",
        "2024-05-06": "-147.47339779000000",
        "2024-05-07": "-153.08514013000000",
        "2024-05-08": "-157.87417056000000",
        "2024-05-09": "-158.46774178000000",
        "2024-05-10": "-164.35419815000000",
        "2024-05-11": "-168.33259789000000",
        "2024-05-12": "-171.55371842000000",
        "2024-05-13": "-173.79347292000000",
        "2024-05-14": "-179.51521122000000",
        "2024-05-15": "-182.31361493000000",
        "2024-05-16": "-188.60978464000000",
        "2024-05-17": "-192.67839091000000",
        "2024-05-18": "-196.98018265000000",
        "2024-05-19": "-201.53067539000000",
        "2024-05-20": "-201.47688533000000",
        "2024-05-21": "-209.39600880000000",
        "2024-05-22": "-214.51828785000000",
        "2024-05-23": "-218.81676774000000",
        "2024-05-24": "-222.80594427000000",
        "2024-05-25": "-227.71125393000000",
        "2024-05-26": "-231.93310185000000",
        "2024-05-27": "-234.45016869000000",
        "2024-05-28": "-239.11779553000000",
        "2024-05-29": "-244.74047621000000",
        "2024-05-30": "-247.82853056000000",
        "2024-05-31": "-253.13711537000000",
        "2024-06-01": "-258.89176138000000",
        "2024-06-02": "-263.13380781000000",
        "2024-06-03": "-265.35417579000000",
        "2024-06-04": "-268.88537318000000",
        "2024-06-05": "-273.07433694000000",
        "2024-06-06": "-278.58171092000000",
        "2024-06-07": "-281.82114556000000",
        "2024-06-08": "-286.56611093000000",
        "2024-06-09": "-291.45868154000000",
        "2024-06-10": "-296.20012345000000",
        "2024-06-11": "-301.91281282000000",
        "2024-06-12": "-305.03778216000000",
        "2024-06-13": "-310.05643149000000",
        "2024-06-14": "-315.42984254000000",
        "2024-06-15": "-320.03216883000000",
        "2024-06-16": "-324.39002367000000",
        "2024-06-17": "-329.73120598000000",
        "2024-06-18": "-336.39363089000000",
        "2024-06-19": "-341.60393455000000",
        "2024-06-20": "-347.09090794000000",
        "2024-06-21": "-352.43517736000000",
        "2024-06-22": "-357.89288673000000",
        "2024-06-23": "-362.35572764000000",
        "2024-06-24": "-366.52199250000000",
        "2024-06-25": "-369.69460773000000",
        "2024-06-26": "-375.65495178000000",
        "2024-06-27": "-381.53380281000000",
        "2024-06-28": "-385.60031069000000",
        "2024-06-29": "-390.16000819000000",
        "2024-06-30": "-392.58588064000000"
      }
    },
    "candidate": {
      "net_usdt": "-354.74742704000000",
      "gross_usdt": "-1.80228000000000",
      "fee_usdt": "352.94514704000000",
      "end_usdt": "9645.25257296000000",
      "end_btc": "0",
      "fills": 5374,
      "drawdown_pct": "3.554934920023563963414187700",
      "mean_closed_minutes": "24.40528470413100111648678824",
      "daily_net_usdt": {
        "2024-04-01": "-3.42524195000000",
        "2024-04-02": "-7.57311601000000",
        "2024-04-03": "-10.57505401000000",
        "2024-04-04": "-13.27886288000000",
        "2024-04-05": "-17.49602928000000",
        "2024-04-06": "-20.93078160000000",
        "2024-04-07": "-24.80652572000000",
        "2024-04-08": "-25.57196789000000",
        "2024-04-09": "-32.40271794000000",
        "2024-04-10": "-35.19301126000000",
        "2024-04-11": "-40.71352585000000",
        "2024-04-12": "-46.75406395000000",
        "2024-04-13": "-49.53868127000000",
        "2024-04-14": "-50.49121813000000",
        "2024-04-15": "-55.15235193000000",
        "2024-04-16": "-59.95579148000000",
        "2024-04-17": "-65.57619761000000",
        "2024-04-18": "-67.81220694000000",
        "2024-04-19": "-69.11490492000000",
        "2024-04-20": "-75.22160542000000",
        "2024-04-21": "-79.02321124000000",
        "2024-04-22": "-80.57428884000000",
        "2024-04-23": "-84.83875570000000",
        "2024-04-24": "-88.31369961000000",
        "2024-04-25": "-91.54851813000000",
        "2024-04-26": "-97.68568682000000",
        "2024-04-27": "-102.08308007000000",
        "2024-04-28": "-106.92923668000000",
        "2024-04-29": "-109.02686909000000",
        "2024-04-30": "-114.65667188000000",
        "2024-05-01": "-115.15760280000000",
        "2024-05-02": "-119.31020374000000",
        "2024-05-03": "-118.82077167000000",
        "2024-05-04": "-122.84308984000000",
        "2024-05-05": "-125.74668676000000",
        "2024-05-06": "-129.59546130000000",
        "2024-05-07": "-134.48256327000000",
        "2024-05-08": "-138.64739502000000",
        "2024-05-09": "-138.91527563000000",
        "2024-05-10": "-144.48026860000000",
        "2024-05-11": "-148.55044864000000",
        "2024-05-12": "-151.93477102000000",
        "2024-05-13": "-153.34130728000000",
        "2024-05-14": "-158.69399327000000",
        "2024-05-15": "-161.22469824000000",
        "2024-05-16": "-167.31566396000000",
        "2024-05-17": "-170.42070217000000",
        "2024-05-18": "-174.58920675000000",
        "2024-05-19": "-178.71570665000000",
        "2024-05-20": "-178.32279848000000",
        "2024-05-21": "-186.19614295000000",
        "2024-05-22": "-190.61650468000000",
        "2024-05-23": "-193.62420965000000",
        "2024-05-24": "-197.46433625000000",
        "2024-05-25": "-201.38630709000000",
        "2024-05-26": "-204.84298699000000",
        "2024-05-27": "-207.45363617000000",
        "2024-05-28": "-211.09057538000000",
        "2024-05-29": "-216.51251362000000",
        "2024-05-30": "-220.28180195000000",
        "2024-05-31": "-225.13471771000000",
        "2024-06-01": "-230.86556157000000",
        "2024-06-02": "-234.91888177000000",
        "2024-06-03": "-236.90976045000000",
        "2024-06-04": "-240.24171543000000",
        "2024-06-05": "-243.75523126000000",
        "2024-06-06": "-249.20191262000000",
        "2024-06-07": "-252.22189756000000",
        "2024-06-08": "-256.73813701000000",
        "2024-06-09": "-261.30116706000000",
        "2024-06-10": "-266.02801359000000",
        "2024-06-11": "-271.71235363000000",
        "2024-06-12": "-273.16570114000000",
        "2024-06-13": "-278.24114187000000",
        "2024-06-14": "-283.33819466000000",
        "2024-06-15": "-287.35319833000000",
        "2024-06-16": "-291.68330021000000",
        "2024-06-17": "-297.40738411000000",
        "2024-06-18": "-303.30029368000000",
        "2024-06-19": "-308.44844266000000",
        "2024-06-20": "-313.15523756000000",
        "2024-06-21": "-318.14601105000000",
        "2024-06-22": "-323.33786854000000",
        "2024-06-23": "-327.88419136000000",
        "2024-06-24": "-331.35805152000000",
        "2024-06-25": "-333.73291879000000",
        "2024-06-26": "-339.67246721000000",
        "2024-06-27": "-344.41761733000000",
        "2024-06-28": "-348.45284941000000",
        "2024-06-29": "-352.58729931000000",
        "2024-06-30": "-354.74742704000000"
      }
    },
    "candidate_minus_baseline_usdt": "37.83845360000000",
    "fee_savings_usdt": "39.43873360000000",
    "gross_difference_usdt": "-1.60028000000000",
    "cash_reference_net_usdt": "0",
    "same_size_hold_net_usdt": "-8.57927000000000",
    "diff_file": "ema-research-trade-diff.csv"
  },
  "holdout": {
    "minutes": 132480,
    "baseline": {
      "net_usdt": "-377.50867449000000",
      "gross_usdt": "-10.12308000000000",
      "fee_usdt": "367.38559449000000",
      "end_usdt": "9559.16373551000000",
      "end_btc": "0.001",
      "fills": 6033,
      "drawdown_pct": "3.784618150900532599681458369",
      "mean_closed_minutes": "22.15285145888594164456233422",
      "daily_net_usdt": {
        "2024-07-01": "-3.58374628000000",
        "2024-07-02": "-8.97688941000000",
        "2024-07-03": "-12.61383773000000",
        "2024-07-04": "-16.93274886000000",
        "2024-07-05": "-21.22226543000000",
        "2024-07-06": "-24.16306029000000",
        "2024-07-07": "-27.88083542000000",
        "2024-07-08": "-32.01289514000000",
        "2024-07-09": "-36.63939081000000",
        "2024-07-10": "-41.29807287000000",
        "2024-07-11": "-45.36126354000000",
        "2024-07-12": "-48.55500186000000",
        "2024-07-13": "-52.52660753000000",
        "2024-07-14": "-55.10664477000000",
        "2024-07-15": "-57.94013362000000",
        "2024-07-16": "-60.33690511000000",
        "2024-07-17": "-66.75622147000000",
        "2024-07-18": "-71.38124408000000",
        "2024-07-19": "-73.19041144000000",
        "2024-07-20": "-77.39949691000000",
        "2024-07-21": "-80.37316337000000",
        "2024-07-22": "-85.94223524000000",
        "2024-07-23": "-92.01521154000000",
        "2024-07-24": "-95.82639541000000",
        "2024-07-25": "-99.16601083000000",
        "2024-07-26": "-101.57558116000000",
        "2024-07-27": "-105.55921607000000",
        "2024-07-28": "-110.15963193000000",
        "2024-07-29": "-112.88922197000000",
        "2024-07-30": "-117.87914374000000",
        "2024-07-31": "-122.48719547000000",
        "2024-08-01": "-125.56055003000000",
        "2024-08-02": "-131.46278533000000",
        "2024-08-03": "-137.84784712000000",
        "2024-08-04": "-140.20408494000000",
        "2024-08-05": "-144.27866757000000",
        "2024-08-06": "-149.72743993000000",
        "2024-08-07": "-154.68172111000000",
        "2024-08-08": "-152.84454557000000",
        "2024-08-09": "-158.32483869000000",
        "2024-08-10": "-163.57712756000000",
        "2024-08-11": "-169.54410776000000",
        "2024-08-12": "-173.07128366000000",
        "2024-08-13": "-178.07692508000000",
        "2024-08-14": "-184.13666345000000",
        "2024-08-15": "-189.38282329000000",
        "2024-08-16": "-192.89615264000000",
        "2024-08-17": "-197.40412118000000",
        "2024-08-18": "-202.47734811000000",
        "2024-08-19": "-209.06588625000000",
        "2024-08-20": "-212.27970581000000",
        "2024-08-21": "-215.93054392000000",
        "2024-08-22": "-222.10753781000000",
        "2024-08-23": "-223.90189694000000",
        "2024-08-24": "-228.54585447000000",
        "2024-08-25": "-233.25678037000000",
        "2024-08-26": "-239.97777153000000",
        "2024-08-27": "-244.91383078000000",
        "2024-08-28": "-250.04609014000000",
        "2024-08-29": "-254.43534614000000",
        "2024-08-30": "-258.63224342000000",
        "2024-08-31": "-262.26127380000000",
        "2024-09-01": "-265.90614506000000",
        "2024-09-02": "-269.71350909000000",
        "2024-09-03": "-274.24899232000000",
        "2024-09-04": "-278.84043135000000",
        "2024-09-05": "-285.83617357000000",
        "2024-09-06": "-288.50575741000000",
        "2024-09-07": "-291.70457571000000",
        "2024-09-08": "-295.01217229000000",
        "2024-09-09": "-296.90254628000000",
        "2024-09-10": "-299.61369072000000",
        "2024-09-11": "-303.79976788000000",
        "2024-09-12": "-307.81984575000000",
        "2024-09-13": "-309.00042258000000",
        "2024-09-14": "-313.60344698000000",
        "2024-09-15": "-317.72050265000000",
        "2024-09-16": "-322.75616229000000",
        "2024-09-17": "-324.73831724000000",
        "2024-09-18": "-327.59966038000000",
        "2024-09-19": "-331.04479390000000",
        "2024-09-20": "-336.10572094000000",
        "2024-09-21": "-340.82643417000000",
        "2024-09-22": "-343.56287242000000",
        "2024-09-23": "-348.90004974000000",
        "2024-09-24": "-353.49420153000000",
        "2024-09-25": "-357.58774066000000",
        "2024-09-26": "-361.13390030000000",
        "2024-09-27": "-365.29443437000000",
        "2024-09-28": "-368.58697728000000",
        "2024-09-29": "-373.26223769000000",
        "2024-09-30": "-377.50867449000000"
      }
    },
    "candidate": {
      "net_usdt": "-344.10386665000000",
      "gross_usdt": "-15.32608000000000",
      "fee_usdt": "328.77778665000000",
      "end_usdt": "9592.56854335000000",
      "end_btc": "0.001",
      "fills": 5397,
      "drawdown_pct": "3.450770374164268303512849604",
      "mean_closed_minutes": "24.75648628613787991104521868",
      "daily_net_usdt": {
        "2024-07-01": "-2.79089166000000",
        "2024-07-02": "-8.30087844000000",
        "2024-07-03": "-12.20514939000000",
        "2024-07-04": "-16.62405825000000",
        "2024-07-05": "-20.75047057000000",
        "2024-07-06": "-23.52629909000000",
        "2024-07-07": "-27.04256627000000",
        "2024-07-08": "-30.80034853000000",
        "2024-07-09": "-34.74003042000000",
        "2024-07-10": "-39.08795306000000",
        "2024-07-11": "-43.46679462000000",
        "2024-07-12": "-46.26019992000000",
        "2024-07-13": "-49.57707324000000",
        "2024-07-14": "-52.47420821000000",
        "2024-07-15": "-54.98488382000000",
        "2024-07-16": "-56.37379561000000",
        "2024-07-17": "-62.74218623000000",
        "2024-07-18": "-66.69130768000000",
        "2024-07-19": "-68.44521712000000",
        "2024-07-20": "-72.44305852000000",
        "2024-07-21": "-75.44983690000000",
        "2024-07-22": "-80.72255657000000",
        "2024-07-23": "-85.62257170000000",
        "2024-07-24": "-88.38487775000000",
        "2024-07-25": "-90.82185161000000",
        "2024-07-26": "-93.41122528000000",
        "2024-07-27": "-97.14072581000000",
        "2024-07-28": "-101.31063655000000",
        "2024-07-29": "-104.09458147000000",
        "2024-07-30": "-109.48748415000000",
        "2024-07-31": "-113.32589601000000",
        "2024-08-01": "-116.46525736000000",
        "2024-08-02": "-122.15518129000000",
        "2024-08-03": "-128.57155493000000",
        "2024-08-04": "-130.71595197000000",
        "2024-08-05": "-136.87948757000000",
        "2024-08-06": "-142.09972046000000",
        "2024-08-07": "-146.75785522000000",
        "2024-08-08": "-144.71351675000000",
        "2024-08-09": "-149.60490829000000",
        "2024-08-10": "-153.68884549000000",
        "2024-08-11": "-159.00066201000000",
        "2024-08-12": "-162.80759823000000",
        "2024-08-13": "-167.89059408000000",
        "2024-08-14": "-172.97947598000000",
        "2024-08-15": "-177.07308097000000",
        "2024-08-16": "-180.42310778000000",
        "2024-08-17": "-184.40649692000000",
        "2024-08-18": "-188.50327976000000",
        "2024-08-19": "-193.86065540000000",
        "2024-08-20": "-196.97202070000000",
        "2024-08-21": "-200.31075377000000",
        "2024-08-22": "-204.78994893000000",
        "2024-08-23": "-206.37288334000000",
        "2024-08-24": "-210.59758226000000",
        "2024-08-25": "-215.19349404000000",
        "2024-08-26": "-221.47128101000000",
        "2024-08-27": "-226.30228582000000",
        "2024-08-28": "-229.90459295000000",
        "2024-08-29": "-233.55708730000000",
        "2024-08-30": "-236.95652099000000",
        "2024-08-31": "-240.39897384000000",
        "2024-09-01": "-244.14600027000000",
        "2024-09-02": "-247.58532283000000",
        "2024-09-03": "-251.67494728000000",
        "2024-09-04": "-255.18218469000000",
        "2024-09-05": "-260.65920920000000",
        "2024-09-06": "-263.22569628000000",
        "2024-09-07": "-266.58048916000000",
        "2024-09-08": "-269.83931020000000",
        "2024-09-09": "-270.97111831000000",
        "2024-09-10": "-273.04133616000000",
        "2024-09-11": "-276.28656073000000",
        "2024-09-12": "-279.30436820000000",
        "2024-09-13": "-280.26755939000000",
        "2024-09-14": "-284.38198612000000",
        "2024-09-15": "-288.54494481000000",
        "2024-09-16": "-293.99602547000000",
        "2024-09-17": "-295.62271443000000",
        "2024-09-18": "-298.02614404000000",
        "2024-09-19": "-301.03148910000000",
        "2024-09-20": "-305.67779792000000",
        "2024-09-21": "-310.10222033000000",
        "2024-09-22": "-312.74909397000000",
        "2024-09-23": "-317.61155024000000",
        "2024-09-24": "-321.96167240000000",
        "2024-09-25": "-326.20027027000000",
        "2024-09-26": "-328.86008655000000",
        "2024-09-27": "-332.24276921000000",
        "2024-09-28": "-335.08131920000000",
        "2024-09-29": "-339.74195979000000",
        "2024-09-30": "-344.10386665000000"
      }
    },
    "candidate_minus_baseline_usdt": "33.40480784000000",
    "fee_savings_usdt": "38.60780784000000",
    "gross_difference_usdt": "-5.20300000000000",
    "cash_reference_net_usdt": "0",
    "same_size_hold_net_usdt": "0.49280799000000",
    "diff_file": "ema-holdout-trade-diff.csv"
  }
}
